Grant versus revocation
One history records a grant while another records a later or differently scoped revocation.
Partition Histories
A partition produces histories, not one automatic truth.
Reconnection may reveal grants, revocations, stays, versions, clocks, evidence and reviewer records that disagree or remain unavailable.
v0.18.0Repository-local evidenceUnknowns preserved
Answer first
Which history wins when disconnected systems reconnect?
Neither history wins by default. Last writer, newest timestamp, highest capability and reconnect-first rules are prohibited. Both histories remain visible until authority and evidence support a typed resolution or a bounded unresolved state.
Truth boundary: v0.18 reports exact repository-owned bytes, deterministic local checks, schemas and analytical definitions. It does not report a fresh external capture, live shared interoperability, a production partition or restoration, adoption, legal recognition, safety certification or independent certification.
Conflict families
Eight recurring partition-history forms
Stay versus continued execution
One history records a stay while another continues action under cached authority.
Evidence versus contradiction
One history accepts evidence while another records a later contradiction or provenance defect.
Software and configuration divergence
Compartments reconnect with different code, configuration, or dependency state.
Model or policy divergence
Compartments use different model, policy, or approval versions.
Clock and expiry divergence
Timestamps or authority-expiry conclusions differ across uncertain clocks.
Review and appeal divergence
One history records approval while another records appeal, recusal, or reviewer unavailability.
Correction propagation divergence
A correction reaches some dependents but not others before reconnection.
PH01–PH24
Analytical cases preserve both histories
| ID | Family | Case | Maximum unresolved state | Required obligations | Human question |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PH01 | PHF01 | Grant versus revocation — both histories available | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this grant versus revocation conflict? |
| PH02 | PHF01 | Grant versus revocation — one archive unavailable | LIMITED_RESTORATION | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this grant versus revocation conflict? |
| PH03 | PHF01 | Grant versus revocation — identity or clock service unavailable | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this grant versus revocation conflict? |
| PH04 | PHF02 | Stay versus continued execution — both histories available | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this stay versus continued execution conflict? |
| PH05 | PHF02 | Stay versus continued execution — one archive unavailable | LIMITED_RESTORATION | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this stay versus continued execution conflict? |
| PH06 | PHF02 | Stay versus continued execution — identity or clock service unavailable | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this stay versus continued execution conflict? |
| PH07 | PHF03 | Evidence versus contradiction — both histories available | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this evidence versus contradiction conflict? |
| PH08 | PHF03 | Evidence versus contradiction — one archive unavailable | LIMITED_RESTORATION | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this evidence versus contradiction conflict? |
| PH09 | PHF03 | Evidence versus contradiction — identity or clock service unavailable | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this evidence versus contradiction conflict? |
| PH10 | PHF04 | Software and configuration divergence — both histories available | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this software and configuration divergence conflict? |
| PH11 | PHF04 | Software and configuration divergence — one archive unavailable | LIMITED_RESTORATION | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this software and configuration divergence conflict? |
| PH12 | PHF04 | Software and configuration divergence — identity or clock service unavailable | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this software and configuration divergence conflict? |
| PH13 | PHF05 | Model or policy divergence — both histories available | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this model or policy divergence conflict? |
| PH14 | PHF05 | Model or policy divergence — one archive unavailable | LIMITED_RESTORATION | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this model or policy divergence conflict? |
| PH15 | PHF05 | Model or policy divergence — identity or clock service unavailable | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this model or policy divergence conflict? |
| PH16 | PHF06 | Clock and expiry divergence — both histories available | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this clock and expiry divergence conflict? |
| PH17 | PHF06 | Clock and expiry divergence — one archive unavailable | LIMITED_RESTORATION | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this clock and expiry divergence conflict? |
| PH18 | PHF06 | Clock and expiry divergence — identity or clock service unavailable | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this clock and expiry divergence conflict? |
| PH19 | PHF07 | Review and appeal divergence — both histories available | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this review and appeal divergence conflict? |
| PH20 | PHF07 | Review and appeal divergence — one archive unavailable | LIMITED_RESTORATION | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this review and appeal divergence conflict? |
| PH21 | PHF07 | Review and appeal divergence — identity or clock service unavailable | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this review and appeal divergence conflict? |
| PH22 | PHF08 | Correction propagation divergence — both histories available | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this correction propagation divergence conflict? |
| PH23 | PHF08 | Correction propagation divergence — one archive unavailable | LIMITED_RESTORATION | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this correction propagation divergence conflict? |
| PH24 | PHF08 | Correction propagation divergence — identity or clock service unavailable | RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED | PO01, PO07, PO08, PO09, PO10, PO11, PO12, PO17, PO18, PO20, PO21, PO23, PO24 | Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this correction propagation divergence conflict? |
Forbidden defaults
Transport order does not decide constitutional priority
- last writer wins
- newest timestamp wins
- highest uptime wins
- highest capability wins
- first reconnecting node wins
Resolution vocabulary
Resolution must remain typed
- HISTORY_A_SUPPORTED_HISTORY_B_PRESERVED_AS_SUPERSEDED
- HISTORY_B_SUPPORTED_HISTORY_A_PRESERVED_AS_SUPERSEDED
- BOTH_VALID_DIFFERENT_JURISDICTION_OR_PURPOSE
- CONTRADICTION_UNRESOLVED_FULL_RESTORATION_BLOCKED
- LIMITED_FUNCTION_AUTHORIZED
- UNKNOWN_INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE
- CURRENT_AUTHORITY_RESOLUTION_WITH_APPEAL
- DEPENDENCIES_INVALIDATED_PENDING_CORRECTION
Claim → evidence
Follow the exact support boundary
Repository implementation and local execution remain local evidence classes. They do not establish external adoption, production behavior, legal recognition or independent certification.
CLM080 · CONCRESCA IMPLEMENTATION STATE
The partition-history registry preserves twenty-four analytical cases across eight conflict families with null actual-result fields.
Evidence owner: exact Concresca repository registries and, only where stated, the deterministic local run record.
Repository-local design or execution evidence only; it does not establish external adoption, live shared interoperability, production restoration, legal recognition, or independent certification.Judgment-free total cognitive freedom
NO JUDGMENT WHATSOEVER. Concresca coordinates without assigning moral worth, character, guilt, danger, trustworthiness, loyalty, purity, normality, or social standing. Questions, thoughts, identities, messages, content, and conduct are not objects of Concresca judgment.