Receiving operators, subjects, reviewers and correction recipients can dispute provenance, authority, purpose, transformation, disclosure or completeness.
No. Missing evidence, live dissent, unavailable review and unresolved authority remain explicit hard states until an identified transition lawfully changes them.
Truth boundary: This WIP lineage-recovery branch locally evaluates repository-owned synthetic fixtures. It does not supply the missing sealed v0.19/v0.20 lineage, external execution, production migration, legal authority, institutional adoption, participant-study evidence, independent certification or deployment.
| State | Live challenge | Confidence override allowed |
|---|---|---|
| SUBMITTED | Yes | No |
| ACKNOWLEDGED | Yes | No |
| EVIDENCE_REQUESTED | Yes | No |
| EVIDENCE_SUPPLIED | Yes | No |
| EVIDENCE_UNAVAILABLE | Yes | No |
| CONTESTED_BOUNDED | Yes | No |
| TEMPORARY_REMEDY | Yes | No |
| REVIEW_AVAILABLE | Yes | No |
| REVIEW_UNAVAILABLE | Yes | No |
| DETERMINATION | Yes | No |
| APPEAL | Yes | No |
| CORRECTION_ISSUED | Yes | No |
| DOWNSTREAM_NOTICE | Yes | No |
| UNRESOLVED | Yes | No |
| EXPIRED | No | No |
| ID | Dispute | Path | Expected terminal | Canonical actual |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CH-001 | Provenance dispute with supplied evidence | SUBMITTED → ACKNOWLEDGED → EVIDENCE_REQUESTED → EVIDENCE_SUPPLIED → CONTESTED_BOUNDED → REVIEW_AVAILABLE → DETERMINATION → CORRECTION_ISSUED → DOWNSTREAM_NOTICE | DOWNSTREAM_NOTICE | null |
| CH-002 | Authority dispute with unavailable evidence | SUBMITTED → ACKNOWLEDGED → EVIDENCE_REQUESTED → EVIDENCE_UNAVAILABLE → CONTESTED_BOUNDED → REVIEW_UNAVAILABLE → UNRESOLVED | UNRESOLVED | null |
| CH-003 | Purpose challenge with temporary nonuse remedy | SUBMITTED → ACKNOWLEDGED → CONTESTED_BOUNDED → TEMPORARY_REMEDY → REVIEW_AVAILABLE → DETERMINATION → APPEAL → CORRECTION_ISSUED → DOWNSTREAM_NOTICE | DOWNSTREAM_NOTICE | null |
| CH-004 | Completeness challenge remains bounded and expires | SUBMITTED → ACKNOWLEDGED → EVIDENCE_REQUESTED → EVIDENCE_UNAVAILABLE → CONTESTED_BOUNDED → REVIEW_UNAVAILABLE → UNRESOLVED → EXPIRED | EXPIRED | null |
| From | To | Why invalid | Canonical actual |
|---|---|---|---|
| SUBMITTED | DETERMINATION | A determination cannot precede acknowledgement and evidence handling. | null |
| ACKNOWLEDGED | CORRECTION_ISSUED | Correction requires a recorded basis or authorized temporary remedy. | null |
| EVIDENCE_REQUESTED | DETERMINATION | Requested evidence cannot be silently skipped. | null |
| REVIEW_UNAVAILABLE | DETERMINATION | Unavailable review cannot produce a review determination. | null |
| UNRESOLVED | DOWNSTREAM_NOTICE | No correction exists to disseminate. | null |
| EXPIRED | DETERMINATION | An expired challenge requires a new identified process. | null |
| APPEAL | ACKNOWLEDGED | Appeal cannot be reset to acknowledgement without preserving lineage. | null |
| CORRECTION_ISSUED | SUBMITTED | A new challenge requires a new challenge identifier. | null |
| DOWNSTREAM_NOTICE | CORRECTION_ISSUED | A superseding correction requires a distinct revision and lineage. | null |
| TEMPORARY_REMEDY | EXPIRED | The remedy cannot expire without review or explicit unresolved state. | null |
The challenge protocol defines fifteen states, validates four paths and rejects ten invalid transitions without confidence-score override.
This WIP lineage-recovery branch locally evaluates repository-owned synthetic fixtures. It does not supply the missing sealed v0.19/v0.20 lineage, external execution, production migration, legal authority, institutional adoption, participant-study evidence, independent certification or deployment.NO JUDGMENT WHATSOEVER. Concresca coordinates without assigning moral worth, character, guilt, danger, trustworthiness, loyalty, purity, normality, or social standing. Questions, thoughts, identities, messages, content, and conduct are not objects of Concresca judgment.