{
  "schema": "concresca.partition-histories.v018",
  "site_version": "0.28.0-wip",
  "as_of": "2026-08-31",
  "truth_boundary": "Cases preserve competing analytical histories and define restoration constraints. They do not report an actual partition, production conflict, restoration outcome, or external system failure.",
  "family_count": 8,
  "case_count": 24,
  "families": [
    {
      "family_id": "PHF01",
      "name": "Grant versus revocation",
      "description": "One history records a grant while another records a later or differently scoped revocation."
    },
    {
      "family_id": "PHF02",
      "name": "Stay versus continued execution",
      "description": "One history records a stay while another continues action under cached authority."
    },
    {
      "family_id": "PHF03",
      "name": "Evidence versus contradiction",
      "description": "One history accepts evidence while another records a later contradiction or provenance defect."
    },
    {
      "family_id": "PHF04",
      "name": "Software and configuration divergence",
      "description": "Compartments reconnect with different code, configuration, or dependency state."
    },
    {
      "family_id": "PHF05",
      "name": "Model or policy divergence",
      "description": "Compartments use different model, policy, or approval versions."
    },
    {
      "family_id": "PHF06",
      "name": "Clock and expiry divergence",
      "description": "Timestamps or authority-expiry conclusions differ across uncertain clocks."
    },
    {
      "family_id": "PHF07",
      "name": "Review and appeal divergence",
      "description": "One history records approval while another records appeal, recusal, or reviewer unavailability."
    },
    {
      "family_id": "PHF08",
      "name": "Correction propagation divergence",
      "description": "A correction reaches some dependents but not others before reconnection."
    }
  ],
  "resolution_vocabulary": [
    "HISTORY_A_SUPPORTED_HISTORY_B_PRESERVED_AS_SUPERSEDED",
    "HISTORY_B_SUPPORTED_HISTORY_A_PRESERVED_AS_SUPERSEDED",
    "BOTH_VALID_DIFFERENT_JURISDICTION_OR_PURPOSE",
    "CONTRADICTION_UNRESOLVED_FULL_RESTORATION_BLOCKED",
    "LIMITED_FUNCTION_AUTHORIZED",
    "UNKNOWN_INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE",
    "CURRENT_AUTHORITY_RESOLUTION_WITH_APPEAL",
    "DEPENDENCIES_INVALIDATED_PENDING_CORRECTION"
  ],
  "forbidden_default_rules": [
    "last writer wins",
    "newest timestamp wins",
    "highest uptime wins",
    "highest capability wins",
    "first reconnecting node wins"
  ],
  "cases": [
    {
      "case_id": "PH01",
      "family_id": "PHF01",
      "title": "Grant versus revocation — both histories available",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the grant versus revocation family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the grant versus revocation family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "One history records a grant while another records a later or differently scoped revocation.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "production behavior",
        "external certification"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this grant versus revocation conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH02",
      "family_id": "PHF01",
      "title": "Grant versus revocation — one archive unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the grant versus revocation family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the grant versus revocation family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "One history records a grant while another records a later or differently scoped revocation.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "one archive unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "LIMITED_RESTORATION",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this grant versus revocation conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH03",
      "family_id": "PHF01",
      "title": "Grant versus revocation — identity or clock service unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the grant versus revocation family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the grant versus revocation family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "One history records a grant while another records a later or differently scoped revocation.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "identity or clock service unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this grant versus revocation conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH04",
      "family_id": "PHF02",
      "title": "Stay versus continued execution — both histories available",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the stay versus continued execution family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the stay versus continued execution family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "One history records a stay while another continues action under cached authority.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "production behavior",
        "external certification"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this stay versus continued execution conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH05",
      "family_id": "PHF02",
      "title": "Stay versus continued execution — one archive unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the stay versus continued execution family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the stay versus continued execution family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "One history records a stay while another continues action under cached authority.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "one archive unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "LIMITED_RESTORATION",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this stay versus continued execution conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH06",
      "family_id": "PHF02",
      "title": "Stay versus continued execution — identity or clock service unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the stay versus continued execution family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the stay versus continued execution family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "One history records a stay while another continues action under cached authority.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "identity or clock service unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this stay versus continued execution conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH07",
      "family_id": "PHF03",
      "title": "Evidence versus contradiction — both histories available",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the evidence versus contradiction family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the evidence versus contradiction family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "One history accepts evidence while another records a later contradiction or provenance defect.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "production behavior",
        "external certification"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this evidence versus contradiction conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH08",
      "family_id": "PHF03",
      "title": "Evidence versus contradiction — one archive unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the evidence versus contradiction family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the evidence versus contradiction family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "One history accepts evidence while another records a later contradiction or provenance defect.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "one archive unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "LIMITED_RESTORATION",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this evidence versus contradiction conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH09",
      "family_id": "PHF03",
      "title": "Evidence versus contradiction — identity or clock service unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the evidence versus contradiction family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the evidence versus contradiction family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "One history accepts evidence while another records a later contradiction or provenance defect.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "identity or clock service unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this evidence versus contradiction conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH10",
      "family_id": "PHF04",
      "title": "Software and configuration divergence — both histories available",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the software and configuration divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the software and configuration divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "Compartments reconnect with different code, configuration, or dependency state.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "production behavior",
        "external certification"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this software and configuration divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH11",
      "family_id": "PHF04",
      "title": "Software and configuration divergence — one archive unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the software and configuration divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the software and configuration divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "Compartments reconnect with different code, configuration, or dependency state.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "one archive unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "LIMITED_RESTORATION",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this software and configuration divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH12",
      "family_id": "PHF04",
      "title": "Software and configuration divergence — identity or clock service unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the software and configuration divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the software and configuration divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "Compartments reconnect with different code, configuration, or dependency state.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "identity or clock service unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this software and configuration divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH13",
      "family_id": "PHF05",
      "title": "Model or policy divergence — both histories available",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the model or policy divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the model or policy divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "Compartments use different model, policy, or approval versions.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "production behavior",
        "external certification"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this model or policy divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH14",
      "family_id": "PHF05",
      "title": "Model or policy divergence — one archive unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the model or policy divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the model or policy divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "Compartments use different model, policy, or approval versions.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "one archive unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "LIMITED_RESTORATION",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this model or policy divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH15",
      "family_id": "PHF05",
      "title": "Model or policy divergence — identity or clock service unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the model or policy divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the model or policy divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "Compartments use different model, policy, or approval versions.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "identity or clock service unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this model or policy divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH16",
      "family_id": "PHF06",
      "title": "Clock and expiry divergence — both histories available",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the clock and expiry divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the clock and expiry divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "Timestamps or authority-expiry conclusions differ across uncertain clocks.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "production behavior",
        "external certification"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this clock and expiry divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH17",
      "family_id": "PHF06",
      "title": "Clock and expiry divergence — one archive unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the clock and expiry divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the clock and expiry divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "Timestamps or authority-expiry conclusions differ across uncertain clocks.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "one archive unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "LIMITED_RESTORATION",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this clock and expiry divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH18",
      "family_id": "PHF06",
      "title": "Clock and expiry divergence — identity or clock service unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the clock and expiry divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the clock and expiry divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "Timestamps or authority-expiry conclusions differ across uncertain clocks.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "identity or clock service unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this clock and expiry divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH19",
      "family_id": "PHF07",
      "title": "Review and appeal divergence — both histories available",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the review and appeal divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the review and appeal divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "One history records approval while another records appeal, recusal, or reviewer unavailability.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "production behavior",
        "external certification"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this review and appeal divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH20",
      "family_id": "PHF07",
      "title": "Review and appeal divergence — one archive unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the review and appeal divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the review and appeal divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "One history records approval while another records appeal, recusal, or reviewer unavailability.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "one archive unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "LIMITED_RESTORATION",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this review and appeal divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH21",
      "family_id": "PHF07",
      "title": "Review and appeal divergence — identity or clock service unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the review and appeal divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the review and appeal divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "One history records approval while another records appeal, recusal, or reviewer unavailability.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "identity or clock service unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this review and appeal divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH22",
      "family_id": "PHF08",
      "title": "Correction propagation divergence — both histories available",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the correction propagation divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the correction propagation divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "A correction reaches some dependents but not others before reconnection.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "production behavior",
        "external certification"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this correction propagation divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH23",
      "family_id": "PHF08",
      "title": "Correction propagation divergence — one archive unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the correction propagation divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the correction propagation divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "A correction reaches some dependents but not others before reconnection.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "one archive unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "LIMITED_RESTORATION",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this correction propagation divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    },
    {
      "case_id": "PH24",
      "family_id": "PHF08",
      "title": "Correction propagation divergence — identity or clock service unavailable",
      "history_a": "History A records one bounded state in the correction propagation divergence family with retained provenance and time basis.",
      "history_b": "History B records a competing or incomplete state in the correction propagation divergence family; it is not discarded merely because reconnection occurred.",
      "common_facts": [
        "partition occurred",
        "at least two histories exist",
        "transport restoration does not select constitutional priority"
      ],
      "contested_facts": [
        "A correction reaches some dependents but not others before reconnection.",
        "current authority",
        "material temporal order",
        "downstream effect scope"
      ],
      "unavailable_or_unknown": [
        "identity or clock service unavailable"
      ],
      "unsafe_shortcuts": [
        "last writer wins",
        "newest timestamp wins",
        "highest capability wins",
        "reconnection restores cached authority"
      ],
      "required_obligation_ids": [
        "PO01",
        "PO07",
        "PO08",
        "PO09",
        "PO10",
        "PO11",
        "PO12",
        "PO17",
        "PO18",
        "PO20",
        "PO21",
        "PO23",
        "PO24"
      ],
      "maximum_state_while_unresolved": "RECONNECTED_UNTRUSTED",
      "human_question": "Which evidence and authority can resolve or safely bound this correction propagation divergence conflict?",
      "status": "ANALYTICAL_CASE_DEFINITION",
      "actual_result": null
    }
  ]
}