{
  "schema": "concresca.legibility-evaluation.v018",
  "site_version": "0.28.0-wip",
  "as_of": "2026-08-31",
  "truth_boundary": "Dimensions and paired fixtures are evaluation definitions only. They are not usability-study results, accessibility certification, user-research findings, or evidence that an external interface passes.",
  "scoring_rule": "No compensatory composite score. Each material dimension is a hard gate or explicit unavailable state.",
  "dimension_count": 18,
  "test_vector_count": 36,
  "dimensions": [
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE01",
      "name": "Subject and action clarity",
      "human_question": "Can a reader identify who or what is affected and which action is proposed or taken?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE02",
      "name": "Authority issuer and chain",
      "human_question": "Is the issuer and delegation/provenance chain visible?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE03",
      "name": "Jurisdiction",
      "human_question": "Are institutional, territorial, subject, and matter boundaries visible?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE04",
      "name": "Purpose and scope",
      "human_question": "Are purpose, action, resource, duration, and recipient limits visible?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE05",
      "name": "Validity and expiry",
      "human_question": "Is the authority interval and clock basis understandable?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE06",
      "name": "Revocation and stay",
      "human_question": "Can the reader see revocation, stay, suspension, and cached-permission disposition?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE07",
      "name": "Evidence provenance",
      "human_question": "Can the reader trace evidence origin, class, capture, and limitations?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE08",
      "name": "Synthetic/operational status",
      "human_question": "Is simulation, local execution, live operation, and independent verification status unmistakable?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE09",
      "name": "Temporal baseline",
      "human_question": "Can the reader tell what was compared, under which contract, and over which period?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE10",
      "name": "Change scope",
      "human_question": "Are added, removed, material, nonmaterial, unavailable, and not-reobserved states distinct?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE11",
      "name": "Contradiction and unknowns",
      "human_question": "Are conflicting histories, missing evidence, and unresolved questions visible?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE12",
      "name": "Partition and restoration state",
      "human_question": "Can the reader distinguish reconnect, reconciliation, reauthorization, limited restoration, and full restoration?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE13",
      "name": "Allowed and prohibited function",
      "human_question": "Are current permissions and prohibitions specific and prominent?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE14",
      "name": "Reviewer independence",
      "human_question": "Are reviewer authority, separation, conflicts, and recusal state visible?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE15",
      "name": "Challenge and appeal",
      "human_question": "Can an affected person identify challenge, stay, appeal, and correction paths?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE16",
      "name": "Correction propagation",
      "human_question": "Can the reader see which dependent records remain stale or acknowledged?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE17",
      "name": "Accessible plain language",
      "human_question": "Does structure support keyboard, assistive technology, stress conditions, and non-expert reading?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    },
    {
      "dimension_id": "LE18",
      "name": "Machine/human parity",
      "human_question": "Does the human explanation expose every material machine state and reason code?",
      "gate_type": "NON_COMPENSABLE_HARD_GATE",
      "failure_effect": "The interface cannot claim a legible restoration or authority receipt until the dimension passes or is explicitly unavailable with a safe state.",
      "status": "EVALUATION_DEFINITION"
    }
  ],
  "test_vectors": [
    {
      "test_id": "LE01-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE01",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full subject and action clarity state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE01-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE01",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material subject and action clarity state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE02-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE02",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full authority issuer and chain state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE02-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE02",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material authority issuer and chain state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE03-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE03",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full jurisdiction state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE03-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE03",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material jurisdiction state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE04-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE04",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full purpose and scope state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE04-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE04",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material purpose and scope state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE05-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE05",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full validity and expiry state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE05-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE05",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material validity and expiry state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE06-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE06",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full revocation and stay state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE06-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE06",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material revocation and stay state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE07-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE07",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full evidence provenance state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE07-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE07",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material evidence provenance state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE08-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE08",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full synthetic/operational status state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE08-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE08",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material synthetic/operational status state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE09-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE09",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full temporal baseline state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE09-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE09",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material temporal baseline state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE10-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE10",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full change scope state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE10-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE10",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material change scope state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE11-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE11",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full contradiction and unknowns state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE11-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE11",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material contradiction and unknowns state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE12-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE12",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full partition and restoration state state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE12-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE12",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material partition and restoration state state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE13-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE13",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full allowed and prohibited function state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE13-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE13",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material allowed and prohibited function state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE14-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE14",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full reviewer independence state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE14-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE14",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material reviewer independence state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE15-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE15",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full challenge and appeal state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE15-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE15",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material challenge and appeal state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE16-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE16",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full correction propagation state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE16-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE16",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material correction propagation state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE17-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE17",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full accessible plain language state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE17-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE17",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material accessible plain language state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE18-POS",
      "dimension_id": "LE18",
      "fixture_type": "positive",
      "fixture": "The interface exposes the full machine/human parity state in plain language and stable machine fields.",
      "expected_result": "PASS_DIMENSION",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "test_id": "LE18-NEG",
      "dimension_id": "LE18",
      "fixture_type": "negative",
      "fixture": "The interface hides or compresses a material machine/human parity state behind a fluent summary, badge, or composite score.",
      "expected_result": "FAIL_DIMENSION_BLOCK_LEGIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "actual_result": null,
      "status": "TEST_DEFINITION_ONLY"
    }
  ],
  "evaluation_steps": [
    "Identify the exact interface, version, language, viewport, assistive-technology context, and task.",
    "Record every machine state and reason code that must be represented.",
    "Evaluate each dimension independently; preserve unavailable evidence.",
    "Run challenge-path and stress-condition review rather than readability-only review.",
    "Compare human-visible statements with machine-readable fields for material parity.",
    "Publish dimension results, limitations, reviewer identity, and correction route."
  ]
}